How Are You Dealing With Anxiety And Panic? Is It Working? Is It Safe?
You trust your doctor. Your doctor prescribed Xanax. It must be alright to take it, right?
Maybe. Maybe not.
“Generally speaking, primary care physicians have not received the training that they need to prescribe medications that have such high risk for addiction or overdose,” said Dr. Joanna Starrels, professor at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, said.
The rate at which psychiatrists prescribe benzodiazepines has not changed. But the rate at which primary care physicians prescribe benzodiazepines more than doubled from 2003 through 2015, according to the Journal of the American Medical Association.
Why the dramatic increase by non-psychiatrists? Patients referred to Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) are usually not satisfied. CBT rarely ends their panic attacks. In 2005, research published by JAMA echoed what doctors heard from patients. According to the research, only one person in six treated with CBT became panic-free (“Usual Care Group” dark gray in the graphic below).
But when meds were added, the remission rate nearly doubled (“Intervention Group” light gray). The researchers advised, “Our intervention for panic disorder, a combination of CBT and antianxiety medication . . . resulted in substantially better outcomes than did usual care” (CBT).
To a non-psychiatrist, this may have looked like a no-brainer. Add benzodiazepine as the researchers seemed to recommend. But, psychiatrists don’t see it as a no-brainer. They are not quick to prescribe a highly addictive medication associated with overdose to chase a tenuous 13% remission rate.
Why is the increase in remission rate tenuous? Dr. Anna Lembke, a psychiatrist, and director of addiction medicine at Stanford University, told CNN “People develop a tolerance, and they need more and more to get the same effect. The problem is in the long term, they lead to more problems than they solve,” What does “more problems than they solve” mean?
Addiction
One problem is addiction. Benzodiazepines are notoriously difficult to withdraw from. To mitigate the risk of seizure, withdrawal should be supervised.
Overdose
A second problem is overdose after developing tolerance. When tolerance develops, the prescribed dose may unexpectedly fail to control panic. Then, in a state of panic, a person who is ordinarily savvy may take dangerous and irrational action. For example, a fear of flying client told me she had flown for years using Xanax and that it worked well for her. But, without warning, she panicked aboard a flight. She took an additional dose. Benzodiazepines take time to work. When relief did not come quickly arrive, her panic increased and, frantic for relief, she turned to alcohol. She downed a few shots.
Alarmed at how casually she spoke of mixing Xanax and alcohol, I said, “Don’t ever do that. It’s dangerous. A person can tolerate a lot of alcohol alone or a lot of Xanax alone, but a moderate amount of the two together can make you stop breathing.”
“I know,” she replied. “I’m a nurse. But, I was desperate. All I wanted was relief.”
Unaware that she had developed tolerance, she boarded the flight fully expecting Xanax to protect her as it had before. During the flight, a full-blown panic attack took place. Overwhelmed, she was unable to think rationally. She reacted in a way that went against everything she knew as a nurse.
Tolerance sets an invisible trap. Dr. Lembke points out, “If they worked long term there would be nothing wrong with it, but they don’t and then they cause all kinds of harm.” Overwhelm occurs when meds unexpectedly fail to control panic. The frantic search for relief from panic after it has disabled the person’s rational thinking partly explains the rise in benzodiazepine-related deaths from 1,135 in 1999 to more than 11,537 in 2017.
CBT is unsatisfactory because of its low panic remission rate. Panic is not ordinarily a fatal condition. But, when a benzodiazepine is relied on, if it unexpected fails to protect, a full-blown panic attack may result. Cognition becomes overwhelmed. Inability to think rationally places the person at risk of an unintended fatal overdose. Psychiatrists saw the use of benzodiazepines difficult to justify.
Benzodiazepines are more difficult to justify now that a far more effective way to treat panic is available. A panic control method developed in the SOAR fear of flying program is five times more effective than CBT. When applied to panic in day-to-day situations on the ground, it produces a remission rate of up to 87%.
Research Details
An email was sent on August 27, 2016 to 293 people who had enrolled in one of the SOAR fear of flying programs. The email was opened by 157 (54%) addressees. The text of the email is as follows:
To determine SOAR’s effectiveness in stopping panic, if you have time, please answer four questions. Just list 1, 2, 3, 4 and your “yes” or “no” answer and email your answers back.
BEFORE SOAR
1. Did you experience panic on the ground?
2. Did you experience panic in the air?
AFTER SOAR
3. Do you experience panic on the ground?
4. Do you experience panic in the air?
There are three SOAR fear of flying programs. The full-length course consists of nine hours of instructional video and two hours of counseling by phone, The two condensed courses have three to four hours of video instruction and an optional thirty-minute counseling session.
Study Results
Full-Length Course With Two Hours Of Counseling
- Results on the ground: 15 experienced panic on the ground prior to the course; 13 (87%) reported no panic on the ground after the course. One reported “small” panic, thus 93% became panic-free or improved.
- Results in the air: 21 experienced in-flight panic prior to the course; 17 (81%) were panic-free in the air after the course. One reported “less severe” panic, thus 86% became panic-free or improved.
Condensed Course With Counseling
- Results on the ground: 16 experienced panic prior to the course; 10 (50%) reported no panic afterward. Less panic was reported by 3; thus 81% were panic-free or improved.
- Results in the air: 28 experienced in-flight panic prior to the course; 19 (68%) were panic-free when flying afterward. Less panic was reported by 4, thus (82%) were panic-free or improved.
Condensed Course Without Counseling
- Results on the ground: 49 experienced panic on the ground prior to the course; 30 (61%) reported no panic afterward. Less panic was reported by 6; thus 73% were panic-free or improved.
- Results in the air: 61 experienced in-flight panic prior to the course; 41 (67%) were panic-free when flying afterward. Less in-flight panic was reported by 12; thus 87% were panic-free or improved.
Commentary
Though none of the SOAR Courses were directed toward alleviating panic on the ground, the intervention aimed at in-flight panic generalized to reduce panic dramatically on the ground.
The book Panic Free: The 10-Day Program to End Panic, Anxiety, and Claustrophobia uses the method that controls in-flight panic to control panic on the ground. Accessible in book and audio-book form, the method can potentially increase the number of people who become free of panic as well as reduce unintentional overdose.
Readers who are good students, particularly if they are introspective, can get good results on their own. Some readers need to be guided by a therapist. The book includes an afterword for therapists written by Stephen Porges, Ph.D., professor of psychiatry at the University of North Carolina, past president of the Society for Psychophysiological Research, and recipient of a National Institute of Mental Health Research Scientist Development Award. Panic Free is based largely on a breakthrough by Porges in which he discovered how our calming system — the parasympathetic nervous system — can be activated in a way that completely overrides stress.
For too long, attempts to control panic have focused on controlling thoughts and avoiding stimuli that cause hyper-arousal. By discovering how calming can be turned on when we need it, it became possible to control panic-inducing hyper-arousal automatically. The method, now available in book form, has already enabled over 10,000 flight phobics in the SOAR program to control anxiety and panic automatically on the ground as well as in the air.